It looks like something bizarre is going on with the page for Mountain streams by Peter Bird. I don't know if he did something when he tried to add an mp3 link or if the page was strange to being with. At any rate, I thought you ought to have a look. Carolus 23:52, 10 July 2008 (EDT)
For some reason, the Beethoven Triple Concerto page does not link to its equivalent at IMDBP. Did you see we're signed up for Web Services? Carolus 00:39, 11 July 2008 (EDT)
Here's another page behaving oddly: Le Nozze di Figaro, K.492. The vocal score does not render at all. Carolus 14:09, 15 July 2008 (EDT)
Here's another page behaving strangely:
Also, the publication history on Danse Macabre Op.40 has vanished, which left a hanging bracket which caused the page to act oddly. (I closed the bracket and it looks OK now, except the publication history is gone.) Carolus 00:47, 23 July 2008 (EDT)
Hi Feldmahler, There is a page called "My F***ing Life". It seems very inappropriate and I wonder if you could take a look. Thanks, Rickmiller.
Hi Feldmahler, I was wondering how page deletions are supposed to work in the current system. On the one hand, when deleting e.g. an empty work page, it might make sense to keep the corresponding imdbp entry, unless there is reason to assume that the information is wrong; but on the other hand, this apparently generates a conflict when someone wants to recreate the page on imslp. See also the message on my talk page. How should we deal with that? --Leonard Vertighel 04:28, 13 July 2008 (EDT)
Hello Feldmahler. Just a thought, but would it be possible to include a section for "Key" in the new IMDBP templates for each composition? Sometimes that's the simplest way to distinguish between pieces with similar titles by the same composer (e.g. Tchaikovsky's three "Valse-Scherzos" !). P.davydov 16:55, 13 July 2008 (EDT)
Feldmahler, for some reason I can't submit/create info. for Strauss' Sinfonia Domestica as it's telling me a work with that name already exists. How can this be fixed? Daphnis 19:01, 20 July 2008 (EDT)
Hi Edward -- so glad the site's back! I've been uploading some Massenet songs and had a question about alphabetization. I understand that placement is chosen automatically when articles are present, but with differences in languages some issues have come up. "Il pleuvait," for instance, in French means "It rained" -- the "Il" is not an article as it would be in Italian, but rather a pronoun and so the song would correctly be alphabetized under I. Is there a way to go in and change the categorization from where it is now in P? Thanks for your help! Massenetique 03:03, 23 July 2008 (EDT)
I reached the file blocked error page,would you have any good ideas to download them,please point it out for me,thank you!
Hello Feldsmahler
Since I I´am new at this excellent page I woul´d like to ask:
1. I the PD rules exactly the same for the retypesettings?
2. I the PD rules exactly the same when the ressetted sheet music is provided from a public place (In my case The Music Libraty of Sweden.
3. I have, since the these works by Albinoni are att the wishlist got hold of these publications. But I doubtful that they are PD (I live in Sweden, EU) in any way,and therefor suiteble for publication at IMSLP?:
a. Concerto a cinque Op. VII No. 5 Für Kenner und Liebhaber No. 4 (Fritz Kneusselin (I know he is born 1917-?)Edition Kneusselin Basel 1968
b. Concerto a cinque op. 9 No. 7 Für Kenner und Liebhaber No. 49 (Fritz Kneusselin (I know he is born 1917-?)Edition Kneusselin Basel 1973.
c. Concerto a cinque in fa op. 9 No. 10 Ricordi 1945 Remo Giazotto (He died in 1998).
Best regards
Daltorps 16:55, 25 July 2008 (EDT)
Hi, when I've tried to download most scores, most just stop after loading the first page or sooner. Then, I tried to save the link as a file in my computer, and when the download finishes, a message comes up saying: "This file is damaged and could not be repaired". When I used IMSLP before it was shut down, I could download every file with no trouble. I currently have dial-up internet, do I need DSL or Cable before I can download these files? The files that I am having trouble with are orchestral scores, parts of orchestral scores, and most solo and duet piano scores. What should I do?
Thanks, Dja
I'm currently using Mozilla Firefox (v.2.0.0.16) as browser. Yes, I am using a download manager, but the downloads always stop when only about 10% of the actual file is downloaded. --Dja 1:25, 28 July 2008 (PST)
I haven't tried to disable the download manager yet, do you know how to do that? No, I can't resume after the file after it's "done", my only options are "open", and "remove". Should I use a different browser like IE? Also, when I download any files from other sites, (like piano.ru) I don't have any problems. Dja 17:20, 28 July 2008 (PST)
Hello again, Feldmahler. I was wondering if it is possible to program two time periods into a composer template. I have tried myself at two pages recently but failed. If possible, please tell me how. I want to become familiar with the mechanics of this site, and, when possible, make this site less biased as to where to draw the line between musical time periods, depending on the composer. Have a nice day. Marcus2 15:42, 26 July 2008 (EDT)
Does excist piano reduction of Webern's "Passacaglia" and can you maybe upload?
Hi Feldmahler -- Question: I'm in the process of uploading all eight volumes of songs by Massenet (160 in total) and was wondering if maybe it might be a good idea to put the files together and categorize them as collections (ie. Mélodies, Volume I) on the main composer page. As it is now I have uploaded about a third of them and there are 77 files on the page, most of which are individual song titles -- This seems a bit messy to me, especially since it is unlikely someone would be looking for an individual song title as very few are well-known (and many have the same name, like Berceuse or Serenade). Ideas? Just thinking of ways to make the site more user-friendly, etc. Thanks! Massenetique 17:10, 3 August 2008 (EDT)
Hi Feldmahler and Mssenetique, Here's one possibility: If the published volumes contain no more than 12-15 songs each, it might me most convenient to have a single workpage for each volume. You could also have separate workpages for the actual song cycles. For Massenet and other French composers, the original publishers frequently issued the songs in volume form - typiclly with a title like Melodies, Livre 1 or something similar - during the composer's lifetime or slightly thereafter. This is certainly true of Heugel, and (in Faure's case at least) Hamelle. This get a lot more problematic in cases like Schubert, where most the songs issued in his lifetime were singles. The trick, I suppose is to determine how the volumes were issued in the composer's lifetime or slightly afterwards - instead of using whatever configuration Kalmus may have happened to throw them together into. In many cases, Kalmus would have followed Heugel's grouping for the volumes they issued. Keep in mind also that Hartmann was absorbed by Heugel starting in 1891, so the Heugel collected volumes from about 1920 or so most likely contain all of the titles first issued by Hartmann. PS: I just did a search on OCLC for Melodies of Massenet issued by Heugel. By 1914, 2 years after his death, Heugel had at least 8 volumes available, in versions for high and low voice. It appears they were issued in 20 songs per volume. Carolus 23:29, 3 August 2008 (EDT)
Makes sense to me. I threw together a fast and dirty Edition page for the volumes as issued by Heugel, just so I won't have to look it up again! Carolus 00:35, 4 August 2008 (EDT)
Feldmahler, would there be any harm in my uploading of parts of the Florent Schmitt catalogue to the site in preparation for the 1st of next year? Seeing as we can easily block access to these until the time is come, and as this would greatly reduce the amount of work on my part (as experienced in the Sibelius marathon at the first of this year) in just a couple short days. What do you say? Daphnis 20:39, 21 August 2008 (EDT)
Just letting you know I have added some bugs at IMSLP:Site development. --Peter talk 05:17, 22 August 2008 (EDT)
I´ve tried several times to reupload a Mozart-file, but nothing has happend. The last time a succeded after I had tried It about five times. Would it be easier to let someone take away that file and upload it again as a new file?. I´ve read that there is problems with surver space.
Best regards
--[[User: DALTORPS (Brian Cohn]] 16:10, 22 August 2008 (EDT)
I try to understand the process for page translation but it is very difficult. You made a lot of changements but i see a lot of contradictions ... I dont know if it will be possible for me to contribute. Where is Leonard Vertighel ? Coulon 01:06, 27 August 2008 (EDT)
Feldmahler, since I can't seem to be able to delete this file: http://imslp.org/imglnks/usimg/7/7c/IMSLP05198-Mahler_-_Lieder_ein_farenden_gesellen_kindertotenlieder__scores_.pdf via the mass image deleter (guess I'm not converting the file name correctly) I was hoping you could do since I'm about to post all new scans that are actually clear of this and the next piece contained within that PDF. Thanks. Daphnis 21:43, 29 August 2008 (EDT)
Hello. What would it take for me to get all the sheet music on a data DVD and shipped to me?
In addition, would it be possible for users to submit an audio file along with the actual sheet music, much as musopen.com does? This would help with recognizing the pieces and to hear what the piece sounds like.
Please email me at zhouf12@gmail.com
Hi Feldmahler,
I'm back for good :) I've started uni again, and we don't have lessons until next Tuesday, which means loads of free time to update the Greek translation of the site and do anything else I can.
I've already translated the News section and fixed some stuff on the Main page and a few other pages, but I also think it would be very important to translate the "Urgent Request" text that appears on every page into Greek and the other languages (with "iflang", I presume) so that more people will have a chance of seeing it and helping you. If you want me to, I can send you the Greek translation so you can update it yourself, if it's a privilage issue.
And I would like to take this chance and ask a few questions to make sure I know how to continue. Firstly, our of the navigation/translation bars, which one is more desirable, the green one (IMSLP:Sitemap) or the gray one (Help:Page_creation)? Moreover, how do I translate the templates of work pages? For example, on this page (randomly chosen), altough the navigation menu on the left is in Greek, and bottom information too, the "Music Files", "Recordings" and "General Information" are not, and neither are their respective fields. I remember this used to work, so the translation must be somewhere. If it isn't, just say the word and I'll have them translated again on the spot :)
Furthermore, I'd like to point out the correct Greek pages for three of the links of the Greek left navigational menu:
The link that links to IMSLP:FAQ (Συνήθεις ερωτήσεις (FAQ)) should lead to IMSLP:Συνήθεις Ερωτήσεις
IMSLP:Sitemap (Χάρτης Ιστοσελίδας) should link to IMSLP:Χάρτης Ιστοσελίδας
and IMSLP:Site_support (Υποστήριξη ιστοχώρου) should link to IMSLP:Υποστήριξη Ιστοσελίδας
Also, should I translate the Browse_by_composer_time_period and Browse_by_genre pages using IFLANG, or should I create new pages in Greek for them, and then give the links to you so you can link to these pages in the menu?
Lastly, I would like to remind you about the MIT project (the issue with the link asking for a username and password) - please let me know if there is any news on that, because I really want to finish this up.
Oh, and one last thing: one the publishers' pages (e.g. Augener) there seems to be the Historical Publication Info template, but none of the options is highlighted. If that's correct, then it's fine, but maybe we should add the name of the publisher page open below the second option to show where is the user at the moment with respect to the rest of the Historical Publication Info page group?
Sorry for the big post, I know you're busy - take your time to reply, I'll be here :)
°jujimufu 12:39, 17 September 2008 (EDT)
P.S. Regarding your last message (1st of October 2007), I would very gladly help Leonard with the translation project, regarding answering technical questions etc. Furthermore, I have already started porting the old code to the mediawiki thing, but I am having problems because although in the code each field is on a seperate line, when I save the page it is all in one line. Any ideas?
Hi Feldmahler, I would like to change my username from Nct to Stephane.Magnenat, which is my real name. Could you do it please ? Thank you. --Nct 02:30, 25 September 2008 (EDT)
Dear Feldmahler, there are many templates for instruments to show the level of playing-quality. As a singer, I want to say, that the voice is also a type of music to indicate. I would like to create new templates with "Bass (Voice)", "Baritone (Voice)", "Tenor (Voice)", "Countertenor (Voice)", "Contralto (Voice)", "Mezzo-Soprano (Voice)" and "Soprano (Voice)". What do you think about? Ahandrich 07:24, 27 September 2008 (EDT)
At the moment, I think, its a bit harder than I thought... Ahandrich 12:24, 13 October 2008 (EDT)
Hi, begining i want to congratulate this initiative on IMSLP, the music need a project to be free and complete and most accessible to all peoples, like wikipedia for knowledge. I not imagine which is most important, but music related, are many other things that can do for music and the portal will help so much. One of then is create besides scores, a interaction with wikipedia, information about music (music theoric, explanations about scores) to help beginners, ie, transform IMSLP in a portal of music in many ways (teaching, comparing, discuting). I'm say it because music today in sumary is many chords played, and musicians, not contribute to aggrandize it, music is like medieval era, specially here in Brazil, delayed and poor. It's a big potential to music exit prehistory and grow up. Regards Jcegobrain 08:13, 29 September 2008 (EDT)
I was wondering if I could post my arrangement of Rite of Spring, for 8 Cellos. YuriyLcello 18:16, 29 September 2008 (EDT)
Dear Feldmahler. There are files only PD on certain continents e.g. prohibited in US or EU... But this comment is everytime written by a man. The time will make the documents free for US and EU-people, too. I think that a program is neccessary to monitor the current state of copyright, otherwise all the existing comments will never change without a reason. Ahandrich 10:29, 8 October 2008 (EDT)
Hi Feld,
I notice the harpsichord sonatas and concertos by Antonio Soler are still in the stack of 1000-odd copyright review items, a year on from the post in the forums where you said you would be contacting the copyright owner. May I ask, what was the outcome of writing to Ray Izumi? (chateaugris.com)
I ask, just so we can start processing them more or less en bloc. To my knowledge, very few of the ~100+ sonatas were ever published, so that the first publication for many of them is likely to have been the urtext complete works publications by Rubio and Marvin [Samuel Rubio (1912-1986); Frederick Marvin (1926- )]. Each published their editions comparatively recently: Rubio in Spain from 1984-87, Marvin in the US from 1976-82. Presumably Izumi's editions are reliant on these publications (unless he has transcribed directly from MS), raising the spectre of copyright violation even in terms of Urtext editions, let alone 50pma or 70pma copyrights that may pertain to editors.
Regards, Philip
Philip Legge ♇ @ © Φ 01:23, 10 October 2008 (EDT)
Hi Feldmahler,
thanks for the note; you will note however that I am thorough, and when I looked at Special:Contributions/Ragman it seemed to me fairly likely that he is either the composer or a close associate; a politely worded message was posted at User talk:Ragman, and a question posed (unanswered at present) over at the forums regarding the current protocol. I was prepared to mark the file !N in good faith and revert it to N if there was a lack of permission; in my experience composers (or their representatives) can be very prickly and easily offended if permission is removed, and you will be damned if you do, damned if you don't, so the two approaches are to tag !N first and deny later, or tag N first and permit later. Carl seems to like posting to the user's talk pages giving 24 hours notice of deletion, but then he has the ability to delete pages and image files; I prefer to give some benefit of doubt that a posting may be legitimate as I don't have the ability to delete. :) Whichever method is to be preferred, arguments should be thrashed out over on yonder forum, then published as policy at IMSLP:Copyright Reviewers as guidance to the CR team. At present the page references typesets but not cases for negotiating with composers, and as I've said, these are best handled diplomatically and politely.
Lastly, for my reference would you forward me a copy of the complaint to pml AT unimelb.edu.au? (Whoops, forgot signature) Regards, Philip Legge ♇ @ © Φ 21:36, 13 October 2008 (EDT)
Hello,
Today Haydn's Piano Sonata Nr 17 is normally attributed to Johann Gottfried Schwan(e(n))berg(er). The Sonata is not in the Complete Edition edited by Christa Landon (and I think not in the Complete Works edited by the Haydn-Institute, but I'm not shure), a new edition under S.'s name was made by the publisher Friedrich Hofmeister (now Leipzig). I wrote a notice under "misc. notes" (perhaps this is not the best place, you can change it, or say to me how to change). I think, we should let the sonata at this place - some visitors may believe it to be by Haydn. But we should add the file in a new composer page. Sorry for the stupid question (I not very good in technical stuff): is it enough to copy the wiki-text under "edit this page" and paste it in another page?
Anyway, there are harsh ideological wars about the correct form of Schwan(e(n))berg(er)s name in the Schwan(e(n))berg(er)-Fan-Club (oh yeah, this exists!). We'll have to find a compromise!
Rarus 19:58, 9 November 2008 (EST)
Feldmahler, here is/was the address for this composition: http://imslp.org/wiki/Pr%C3%A9lude%2C_Marine_%26_Chansons_(Ropartz%2C_Guy). Maybe something with the ampersand is wreaking havoc with the formatting. Would you mind having a look? Thanks. And hope all is going well with you. Daphnis 11:46, 30 November 2008 (EST)
Just wanted to pop in and say how much I like the new portal page! It's great!Snailey Yell at me Email me 11:45, 7 December 2008 (EST)
Now that this is a featured score (The complete sonatas, that is), could you please find the time to upload No. 4, if you have it? It would be nice to complete the listSnailey Yell at me Email me 12:39, 9 December 2008 (EST)
Best Feldsmahler.
Even if I have some uploaded file to IMSLP, I have have problems to upload other stuff. I´ve have checked my PDF:s , wich are not large, and thay seem to be OK, with the right endings. I know some others that has had problems to upload. Can it be that my computor´s memorty is to small?
I hope you can give an answer since think this is otherwise an exellent site/project.
Best regards
DALTORPS (Brian Cohn) DALTORPS 14:32, 23 January 2009 (EST)